• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Benvenuto’s II

At Benvenuto’s II, every bite tells a story steeped in Italian tradition. Located at 1859 E Main St, Mohegan Lake, NY, this vibrant eatery serves up artisanal pizzas and mouthwatering appetizers that capture the essence of Italy. With a menu boasting vegan and vegetarian options, it caters to diverse palates, ensuring everyone finds their favorite dish. The casual yet classy ambiance invites patrons to enjoy delightful meals, whether dining indoors or on the covered outdoor patio. With attentive waiter service and a full bar, Benvenuto’s II is the perfect spot for family dinners or a night out. Join us for an experience that warms the heart and excites the taste buds!

LOCATIONS

Welcome to Benvenuto’s II, a charming haven for Italian cuisine nestled in the picturesque Mohegan Lake, NY. This restaurant is not just about feeding the body; it’s about feeding the soul with flavors that capture the essence of Italy. From their hearty pizzas to an array of tantalizing appetizers, the dining experience here is designed to please every palate.

Location and Atmosphere: Located at 1859 E Main St, Mohegan Lake, NY, Benvenuto’s II presents a casual yet classy environment perfect for any occasion. The vibrant ambiance is complemented by trend-inspired decor and moderate noise levels, making it ideal for family dinners, celebratory gatherings, or even a cozy night out with friends.

Menu Highlights: The menu is a delightful fusion of traditional Italian delicacies and contemporary favorites. From their mouthwatering **Burrata Caprese**, featuring fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, and kalamata olives, to the sizzling **Fried Calamari**, every dish is prepared with high-quality ingredients to ensure a remarkable dining experience. Not to forget the **Eggplant Rollatini**, which will surely please both vegan and vegetarian diners, showcasing the restaurant's commitment to accommodating diverse dietary choices.

For the Pizza Lovers: As a pizzeria at heart, Benvenuto’s II crafts pizzas that are the crown jewel of their menu. Each pie is made from fresh dough, layered with rich sauces, and topped with an assortment of ingredients that highlight Italian flavors. Whether you prefer classic toppings or innovative creations, you will find joy in every bite.

Family-Friendly Features: Benvenuto’s II caters to all, offering wheelchair accessibility, gender-neutral restrooms, and even a cozy outdoor seating area where you can enjoy your meal with furry friends, thanks to their dog-friendly policy. They boast numerous utilities, including on-site parking, waiter service, and complimentary Wi-Fi for a leisurely experience.

Extras: Don’t miss their happy hour specials where you can unwind with refreshing beverages at the full bar. For those who are always on the go, Benvenuto’s II offers delivery and takeout, ensuring you can savor their delectable dishes anywhere.

Final Thoughts: Experience the warmth of Italian hospitality at Benvenuto’s II. With a welcoming ambiance, a diverse menu, and thoughtful amenities, this restaurant truly excels in delivering delightful dining experiences. Whether you're here for dinner or dessert, every visit is a celebration of flavor and community.

For reservations or inquiries, call them at (914) 528-7000 and get ready to embark on a culinary journey at Benvenuto’s II!

START YOUR REVIEW OF Benvenuto’s II
Etleva Nacaj
Etleva Nacaj

I recently had the pleasure of dining at Benvenuto II in Mohegan Lake, and it exceeded all my expectations! From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere felt warm and inviting, thanks in no small part to the incredibly friendly and ...

Diana Gjonaj
Diana Gjonaj

I had the pleasure of stopping by this restaurant to celebrate a birthday, and I was absolutely blown away! From the moment I walked in, the atmosphere and ambiance set the perfect tone for a special evening. The decor and vibe were warm ...

Terry Otis
Terry Otis

Small intimate restaurant with phenomenal food. Family owned.. Renata and her sons make an impressive experience. Cocktails excellent ...

Jennifer Juarez
Jennifer Juarez

This is my fifth time here and yet again every dish was exceptional. Drove 45 minutes to bring my friends from out of town and we raved about how delicious every dish is. The service is wonderful and welcoming. We were treated like ...

Erica Valeri
Erica Valeri

So inconspicuous...the best Italian meal from the very humble, simple Chef Andrea Margiotta! He his staff made our Easter dinner beyond memorable! Cant wait to return. Btw...Forgot to take a picture of the Grandma pie. Delizioso!!

Jeremy F
Jeremy F

While I was driving through the area, I was really hankering some great Italian food and thought since I was in NY what better place to try and find some. Lo and behold I come across this place Benvenuto 2, I was able to walk in on a busy ...

JANE EMERY
JANE EMERY

We dine in every week. Chef Andrews menu and specials are delicious and the staff is the friendliest around. Last nights meal was Chicken Italiano and Pumpkin Pizza absolutely delicious! Wow a musttry!

Alexandra Djonovic Brito
Alexandra Djonovic Brito

I traveled from NJ for a family dinner and was warmly greeted by the staff. The place was busy, mostly with locals, which was a good sign. Service was excellentattentive and helpful. ...